2003 Annual General Meeting



Minutes of the Annual General Meeting of the

New Zealand Petanque Association Incorporated, held at

Petanque Mt Albert Clubrooms, Saturday 22 February 2003, 7.30pm

 

Present:

Craig McKenzie, Neil Satherley, Louis Mesnage, Lynette Mesnage, Rosie Muir, Sue Neilson, Neil Dykes, Brenda Dykes, Gordon Dykes, Barb Johnston, Elizabeth Rocks, Michael Rocks, Mark Richardson, Mark Choveaux, Warren McConnell, Joan Miller, John Maxwell, Anita Fletcher, Fran Beach, Grant Hackett, Margaret Fleck, Michael Emerson, Seti Mailei, Imelda Mailei, Pa Peni, Rita de Beer, Peter de Beer, Rex Wood, Lisa McGowan, Ella Harris, Roy Zeier, Sharon Cannon, Roy Cannon, Maurice Manuel-Belz, Christian Fouquet, Graeme Morris, Brian Smith, Barbara Whittington, Ian Baker, Murray Porter, Steve Thwaites, Trevor Neilson.

 

Apologies: Terry Holt, Cam Calder, Peter Whittington, Andy Gilbert, Jane Gilbert, Richard Swaney, Ann Clayworth,.

 

Minutes of Previous Meeting:

Previously distributed; taken as read. Minutes adopted, moved Barbara Whittington, seconded Brian Smith.

 

Matters Arising:

Barbara reported that the following matters arising from the 2002 AGM had been dealt with:

  • Draft constitution had been distributed, with no provision for individual membership.

  • Alternative to current seeding system. The Committee decided that the current seeding system should remain in place. Brian noted that there seemed to be confusion between seeding and grading (ranking) systems. The current seeding system is not perfect, but it does what it is designed to do, ie position players in Pools for tournaments. This aim is why current form is used, rather than past performance. It is fair statistically; everyone has a chance, and each game has to be won on merit – there is no guarantee of progressing to further rounds or the finals.  A grading system is not relevant at the moment.

  • Honorarium for Editor. The Committee has agreed that in view of the co-opted nature of the position, and the specialist skills involved, that an amount of $500 per year should be paid to the Publishing Editor.

Reports:

President’s Report

Graeme read his report and moved its adoption; seconded Michael Rocks. Unanimously accepted by the meeting.

 

Financial Report

Brian Smith presented the accounts for the year ended December 2002. He noted that they had been audited but not yet signed as the auditor had been away.  Brian spoke to his report.  He noted that after the report had been written, Peugeot had come back on board with their sponsorship for the current year.

 

He also outlined changes to SPARC’s funding system, which mean that we will not have an annual grant or entitlement. SPARC now has set criteria that organisations will have to meet before they will be considered for funding, and we will have to show how we are contributing to their objectives in order to receive any funding. 

 

He also noted that Community Trusts are also changing their funding criteria, for example requiring affiliation to a national body as a condition of grants.

 

There were some questions from the floor:

  • Whether PNZ is close to meeting SPARC’s criteria.  The answer was yes, but one of the pivotal requirements is a robust constitution and governance/management structure.  The Committee will also be seeking information and assistance from Clubs and the regions to show how petanque is contributing to NZ becoming a more active nation.

  • Payment of Oceania affiliation fees – Brian said that these had not yet been paid as he had not received a proper invoice. Christian said he would follow this up with the Federation.

  • Why was there no entry for postage and stationary in 2001 – because it was included in with magazine expenses; separated out in 2002.

  • Breakdown of world championships income and expenses – Brian said that this was available to any one who wanted to see it.

  • Peugeot seem to get a lot of publicity in return for what is a quite minor amount – Committee aware of this, but while there is no other major sponsor in the offing do not think it is major concern.

  • Breakdown of committee meeting expenses – mainly travel and accommodation; unavoidable with regional representation.

The accounts were moved for adoption by (moved Brian Smith, seconded  Barbara Whittington) and unanimously accepted

 

Notice of Motion:

The motion to adopt a new constitution was put to the meeting: “that the current Rules of the New Zealand Petanque Association be repealed and replaced in their entirety by the new Constitution appended hereto, with immediate effect.”  Moved Barbara Whittington, seconded Brian Smith.

 

The motion was discussed.

  • Grant Hackett said that he did not think the Constitution was in a form that could be adopted at the moment; some major changes were required to a number of clauses, particularly in respect of definition of membership.

  • Barbara advised that a legal review of the draft Constitution had been received after the draft had been circulated. In view of suggested changes, she moved an amendment to the motion, that “ the new Constitution be adopted subject to the approval of a Working Group appointed by the meeting, of changes including a process for voting for regional Delegates; the National Council as the appeal body for decisions of the Executive; and provisions to allow the National Council to establish committees for this and other purposes”.

  • This was to give a way forward so that the adoption of a new Constitution would not be subject to a further lengthy delay.

  • Rosie Muir said that if we repealed the existing Constitution and didn’t adopt a new one outright, PNZ would have no Constitution until the redrafted one was adopted at another General Meeting.

  • Graeme Morris tabled and read a letter from Cam Calder supporting the retention of the current Constitution.

  • Brian Smith commented that it is imperative that we have a new Constitution if we are to have any hope of gaining funding from SPARC.  Our current Constitution is not acceptable to them.

Michael Rocks moved a further amendment, that Clause 5.6 be extended to allow for paid life membership. Seconded Margret Fleck.

 

The second amendment was voted on and passed on voices.

 

The first amendment was put to the meeting and declared passed on a show of hands, 19 for 14 against.

 

Grant Hackett, Michael Emerson, Rosie Muir and Barbara Whittington were elected to form the Working Group to make the alterations to the draft constitution.

 

It was subsequently found that the motion had, under the then current Constitution, required a 75% majority of those present and voting to be passed, and had therefore in fact been lost. 

 

It was decided that the working group should redraft the proposed Constitution, which will then be put for adoption at a special general meeting later in 2003.

 

The motion that as an interim measure the existing Committee continue in the capacity of Executive until the election of a National Council at the 2004 AGM was moved by Barbara Whittington, seconded Brian Smith. The motion was passed unanimously.

 

Election of Officers:

Not required because of previous motion.  Graeme Morris noted that Terry Holt from Dunedin was standing down from the Committee, and proposed that the position be left vacant in the interim.  The Southern region has been invited to nominate a replacement, for the Committee to co-opt.

 

Graeme proposed a vote of thanks to Terry for all his work on the Committee over the past three years.

 

Appointment of Auditor:

Peter Whittington had advised his availability as auditor again, and was duly appointed.

 

Annual Subscription:

The Committee recommended to the meeting that annual fee for membership of PNZ for the year to 31 December 2003 remain at $5 to be paid through Clubs.  (Moved Brian Smith, seconded Barbara Whittington).

 

The proposal was put to the vote and carried unanimously.

 

General Business:

Seeding

  • Seeding

    • Michael Rocks moved his notice of motion “that the NZPA investigate options for the introduction of a national player rating system and that the current seeding and secondary seeding systems be replaced by 2004”; seconded Roy Zeier. 

    • Michael spoke to the motion, noting that the current seeding system is limited in coverage, very hard to gain points, and provides little incentive for players to do so. A rating system would provide more information to players and would assess a greater range of players.

    • Discussion followed, mainly centred around the high administration costs, especially time, involved in running such a system.

    • The motion was put to the vote and lost on a show of hands.

  • Magazine

    • Circulation – Grant Hackett stated that the magazine is the main means of communication to members and circulation shouldn’t be cut back.  Barbara Whittington advised that Clubs will still get copies in proportion to the number of members. Brian Smith noted that PNZ cannot afford to send one copy per member, unless subscriptions are raised substantially. Christian Fouquet said that $10 a year is not expensive, if people are really interested in petanque they will pay; if not, they wont’ – have choice.

    • A suggestion was made that the magazine be put on the website.  The Committee agreed to look at this possibility.

  • Composition of World Championships Teams

    • Seti Mailei asked what the situation would be if a team with more than one female member won the current Triples and therefore qualified to go to the World Champs, as the FIPJP currently only allows one female member per team.  Graeme agreed that we will have to contact the FIPJP to clarify the situation, urgently depending on the outcome of the current tournament.

  • Entry fee for National Championships

    • Seti asked why the entry fee had been raised to $25 per player; felt it was getting too high.  Brian referred to the financial situation shown in the accounts, noting that PNZ still had to find $5000 to send a delegate to the international annual meeting, even if the team pf players was self-funding.

The meeting closed at 8.45pm

 

Barbara Whittington

Secretary.

 



Home                                                                                                                                                    Top of Page